_revised.jpg) |
| Paul Lynch at the international literary festival ActuaLitté, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons |
[Opening]
Distinguished guests, fellow readers, lovers of stories that both haunt and inspire: thank you for being here.
Today, I want to talk about a novel that has resonated deeply in our times, a work of urgent fiction that looks at our world through a refracted mirror — showing us not only what could happen, but what may already be happening.
That novel is Prophet Song by Paul Lynch, published in 2023.
This is a speech in three parts: first, a lucid summary of the novel — its plot, characters and setting; second, an exploration of its form, themes, and what Lynch is doing as a writer; and third, a case for why Prophet Song is a book of special importance — why we should read it, why it matters now, and why it leaves a mark.
 |
| Paul Lynch ActuaLitté, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons |
[Part I: Summary – What Happens in Prophet Song]
Imagine Ireland — which many of us think of as stable, democratic, with cherished traditions of freedom and rule of law — sliding, almost imperceptibly at first, into something darker.
A government arises, the National Alliance Party, pushing through emergency powers, undermining democratic norms.
They establish new state institutions with surveillance powers; a secret police (the GNSB, Garda National Services Bureau) emerges. The constitution is suspended; rights erode. Citizens begin to disappear.
Into this world we enter the life of Eilish Stack, a scientist and mother of four, an ordinary woman awakened into extraordinary peril. Late on a dark, wet evening in Dublin, two plain-clothes officers of the GNSB come to her door.
They are looking for her husband, Larry Stack, a union official — a high-ranking leader in the Teachers’ Union of Ireland. Larry has been involved in organizing peaceful marches and protests. This, in the new order, is dangerous.
By the end of the novel’s opening chapter, Larry is “disappeared”: arrested, detained without official charges or due process. From this act — the removal of Larry from his home, from his family — the nightmare begins for Eilish and for her children.
With Larry gone, Eilish is left to hold together the falling pieces: their four children, each with their own fears and vulnerabilities; her elderly father, suffering from dementia; the home that is no longer a sanctuary; a city, a society she has always believed in, now bending, cracking, perhaps about to shatter.
She must navigate this unmooring: finding food, shelter, security, information; trying to protect her children from ideological recruitment; trying to keep hope alive even as free speech, privacy, trust, law, and kindness recede.
Over the course of the book, the tension escalates. The government tightens its grip. Dissent becomes dangerous. State violence and disappearances multiply. Protests are suppressed. Foreign media are censored or expelled. People begin to leave, or attempt to leave; others resist from the inside.
Eilish, in the middle of it all, becomes not only a witness but a fighter — for her family, her dignity, her belief in what her country once was, what it might have been, and what it might yet be.
All the while, Lynch’s prose presses in on us. The narration is closely aligned with Eilish’s point of view. Her fears, her hopes, her memories: these are what we experience. Some of the features of the style are disorienting: long sentences that twist and wind; very few paragraph breaks; dialogue often unmarked by quotation marks; a continuous momentum that gives little respite.
It is as if the pressure of Eilish’s world — the political pressure, the domestic pressure, the emotional pressure — has seeped into the form itself.
By the end, the reader is left with certain questions unanswered — not because Lynch fails to resolve, but because the novel intends to unsettle, to leave us in a space of moral ambiguity. What will happen to Eilish’s family?
How far will she go to save them? What is being sacrificed in order to survive? And what do we, as readers or citizens, owe to the world when democracy is fragile?
|
| Paul Lynch ActuaLitté, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons |
[Part II: Form, Themes, Style — What Makes Prophet Song Unique]
Now, let us step back and consider how Prophet Song does what it does. What are its artistic strategies, and what themes resonate so fiercely?
-
Form and Prose StyleOne of the most striking things about Prophet Song is its reservoir of urgency built into its form. The long, winding sentences, the lack of frequent paragraph breaks, the sparse dialogue punctuation — these choices are not gimmicks.
Also, the narrative is told almost always from Eilish’s perspective. We see what she sees, fear what she fears, wonder what she wonders. There is no panoramic, distant view; there is no escape. This keeps the reader tethered to the personal, the domestic — the home, the children, the relationships — even as the political becomes monstrous.
- They are the means by which Lynch immerses the reader in Eilish’s experience: high tension, claustrophobia, confusion, fear, exhaustion. The world is slipping, the ground under Eilish’s feet is moving. These structural features make the experience visceral: you feel the oppressive swirl, the unrelenting pressure of a decaying public life.
-
Themes: Totalitarianism, Family, Resistance, EmpathyProphet Song is a warning: about how democratic norms can erode, how zeroing in on the “other,” the dissenters, the unions, the critical voices, can be a point of fracture; about what can happen if fear is weaponized, if constitutional protections are dismissed, if surveillance becomes normalized. But it is not only a political novel in that sense. It is a deeply human novel about family: what it means to be responsible for others; what love demands in crises; what mothering means when the world outside threatens your children.
It is also about loss — loss of trust, loss of safety, of normalcy. Eilish’s father’s dementia is more than a subplot; it is symbolic. It shows how memory fails, how the past recedes, how forgetfulness is both literal and metaphorical. When people forget what democracy feels like, forget what law means, forget what neighbors once were, a dangerous vacuum opens up.
Empathy is central. Lynch himself has said he wanted an immersion so deep that the reader not only would understand but feel Eilish’s problem for themselves. That attempt at “radical empathy” is what gives the novel its emotional force. Readers are not simply watching a dystopia, they are living in it, for a time. And that has resonance today, in a world where many countries are dealing with polarization, rising authoritarianism, civil unrest, or the erosion of civil liberties.
-
Timeliness and UniversalityThough the book is set in an Ireland that has diverged into far-right politics, secret police, and emergent tyranny, the hazards it depicts are not foreign. Lynch has said that he was inspired by events such as the Syrian civil war, the refugee crisis, and “the West’s indifference” toward suffering. Those are real-world realities. Thus the novel serves as both mirror and warning: we see our world in it; we see what may happen when complacency sets in, when fear is stoked, when legal norms are treated as optional.
Yet, simultaneously, it has universal themes: power and its abuse; the role of the individual versus the state; what happens when people surrender small freedoms in the hope of safety; what resistance means — both internal resistance of maintaining dignity, truth, care, and external resistance of protest, of moral refusal.
-
Emotional & Moral WeightProphet Song does not permit easy comfort. It does not offer cheap heroics or melodramatic solutions. It is unflinching in its depiction of oppression, fear, disappearance. But it is also full of love, familial loyalty, sorrow, moral courage. These are not abstract; they are lived. Eilish is not a superhero. She is flawed, scared, often uncertain. Her decisions are sometimes conflicting. Her strength comes in part from her vulnerability.
The novel also explores grief: for what is lost — not only lives, but ways of being; for what was ordinary that is now impossible; for memory, for trust. And when something is taken — the right to speech, the comfort of routine, the belief that one’s institutions will protect one — what remains is the strength to endure, to act despite despair, and to love despite fear.
|
| Paul Lynch ActuaLitté, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons |
[Part III: Why Prophet Song Is a Special Novel to Read]
Having laid out what Prophet Song contains, now I want to make a case: why this is a novel of special importance. Why, if you are looking for literature that matters — that strikes you, teaches you, unsettles you — this book deserves your time.
-
It acts as a warningStories have power to warn before damage is complete. Prophet Song reminds us that democracy, rule of law, civil rights are not indestructible. They require our attention, our care, our vigilance. In places we might not expect — our own cities, our own countries — the veneer of normalcy can mask fissures. This novel pulls back that veneer.
Reading it can sharpen awareness — of the fragility of institutions; of how small erosions (laws suspended, informal coercion, surveillance) can lead somewhere very dark. When citizens allow fear to dictate politics, when dissent becomes criminalized, when “order” is prioritized over justice, there begins a dangerous drift. Prophet Song makes that drift visible at an intimate level.
-
It is a deeply human storyAmid the political and the dystopian, this novel stays grounded in family, in motherhood, in what ordinary people do to survive. Because of that, it is not just a novel for those interested in politics or dystopia; it is a novel for anyone who cares about people, relationships, care, love, suffering. Many readers have said that Eilish’s struggle, her fear, her love, make you hold your breath; make you ache for her family; make you examine your own convictions: what you would do in her place, how you might respond if you saw freedoms eroded, if loved ones were threatened.
The moral questions are not hypothetical — they feel immediate.
-
Its style intensifies experienceThe structural and stylistic choices — the breathless sentences, the minimal breaks, the closeness of viewpoint — are not ornament; they are essential. They don’t allow for complacency. They force the reader to endure with Eilish. The tension is not only in what happens, but in how the story is told. This makes reading Prophet Song not merely an intellectual exercise but an emotional and ethical one.
-
It speaks to our current eraWe live in times marked by political polarization, by challenges to democratic norms, by debates about freedom of speech, by concerns about surveillance, disinformation, state powers, migration, nationalism. Prophet Song resonates because many of us have seen, or feel, some of these things already: perhaps not secret police exactly, but threats to institutions; perhaps not overt dictatorship exactly, but laws being stretched, norms being tested; perhaps migration crises, refugee suffering, civic unrest, polarized identities.
It is timely, yes — but also, not only timely. It anchors its warnings in something more enduring. It asks: what does it mean to be a moral agent when public life turns cruel? How do we preserve dignity, connection, love when fear is everywhere?
-
It is literary artThe novel has been recognized with the 2023 Booker Prize. Critically it has been praised as a “triumph of emotional storytelling, bracing and brave.”
It is a work that pushes at the boundaries of narrative form. It tests what we expect of dialogue, scene, structure. It asks the reader to stay with discomfort, with ambiguity. That is literary courage. And it has been rewarded because it delivers. It is more than warning; it is also artistry, compelling writing, memorable characters.
|
| Paul Lynch at the international literary festival ActuaLitté, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons |
[Part IV: Challenges & Reflection]
Before I close, I would also offer a few caveats / reflections, because reading Prophet Song is not easy — and we must acknowledge that.
-
It is emotionally taxing. The constant pressure, the tragedy, the fear can be exhausting. It demands from the reader a willingness to sit with discomfort, to face loss, to dwell in ambiguity.
-
Its style — long sentences, minimal breaks, dialogue not marked with quote marks — can be challenging. It requires patience and immersion. But precisely those difficulties are part of what make it powerful.
-
Some readers may find it bleak. There are no tidy moral resolutions. There is sorrow, injustice, and some things unredeemed. The novel does not offer easy answers — nor does it pretend to.
Yet, I believe these are not flaws so much as necessary parts of what the book is doing. To soften the edges would be to dilute its message.
[Conclusion]
Ladies and gentlemen, in Prophet Song, Paul Lynch has given us not only a story of what might happen but a probe into what is happening in many places. He invites us to see, to feel, to question, to act. Eilish Stack’s struggle is not a distant fantasy: it is a prism through which we may understand our own world — the threats, the fractures, the choices — and perhaps find in it a call to safeguard what we hold dear.
This novel matters because it refuses complacency. It preserves dignity in crisis. It dramatizes the sacrifices that liberty requires. It challenges us to ask: What are we willing to protect? What are we willing to resist? What kind of moral courage will we show if the door comes knocking?
So, I urge you: read Prophet Song. Read it not just for its political insight, but for its emotional truth. Read it for the way it draws you in, unsettles you, makes you ache — because those are the books that stay. They change us. They linger in memory. They shape our convictions.
When you finish the last sentence, when the page closes, you may find yourself looking out in the world anew — more watchful, more compassionate, more alive to the fragility and the power of what we sometimes take for granted: democracy, family, justice, the simple faith that ordinary people can make resistance possible.
Thank you.
_revised.jpg){kind=link}
_(cropped).jpg){kind=link}