 |
| Джеймс Эндрюс, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons Porträit of Jane Austen. |
SHORT SUMMARY
Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen tells the story of the Dashwood sisters, Elinor and Marianne, as they navigate love, loss, and societal expectations in late 18th-century England. The novel explores the contrasting approaches to life embodied by the sisters: Elinor, who represents "sense" or reason and prudence, and Marianne, who embodies "sensibility" or intense emotion and romantic idealism.
The story begins with the death of Henry Dashwood, leaving his second wife and three daughters (Elinor, Marianne, and Margaret) with a significantly reduced inheritance. Due to archaic laws, their family estate, Norland Park, passes entirely to Henry's son from his first marriage, John Dashwood, and his avaricious wife, Fanny. Fanny, particularly cruel, ensures the Dashwood women receive very little financial support, forcing them to seek more affordable lodgings.
They eventually move to Barton Cottage in Devonshire, a property owned by a distant relative, Sir John Middleton. Here, their lives intertwine with a new circle of acquaintances. Elinor, reserved and thoughtful, develops a quiet affection for Fanny's brother, Edward Ferrars, a modest and kind gentleman. However, Edward's diffidence and the disapproval of his ambitious family, who expect him to marry into wealth, create obstacles. Elinor, ever discreet, keeps her feelings and their burgeoning connection private, even from Marianne.
Marianne, on the other hand, with her passionate and unreserved nature, quickly falls in love with the dashing and seemingly perfect John Willoughby. Their whirlwind romance is characterized by grand gestures and open displays of affection, much to Elinor's quiet concern. Marianne believes Willoughby to be her soulmate and expects a swift proposal. However, Willoughby abruptly departs for London, leaving Marianne heartbroken and bewildered, offering no explanation.
Adding to the romantic complications is the steady and dependable Colonel Brandon, a considerably older gentleman who has fallen deeply in love with Marianne. His quiet devotion and responsible nature are initially overlooked by Marianne, who is infatuated with Willoughby's more flamboyant charm.
The plot thickens when the Dashwood sisters visit London. There, they encounter Willoughby, who now treats Marianne with cold indifference. The truth of his character is revealed: he is a dissolute fortune-hunter who has abandoned Marianne to marry a wealthy heiress. Marianne is devastated, falling into a deep depression and later a life-threatening illness.
Simultaneously, Elinor's quiet suffering intensifies. She learns that Edward Ferrars has been secretly engaged for years to Lucy Steele, a manipulative and conniving woman who uses this secret to torment Elinor. Elinor, despite her heartbreak, maintains her composure and dignity, showcasing her remarkable self-control.
The climax sees Marianne recovering from her illness, her romantic illusions shattered. She begins to appreciate Colonel Brandon's steadfast love and realizes the folly of her earlier impulsiveness. Edward Ferrars, released from his engagement to Lucy Steele (who elopes with his younger brother), is finally free to declare his true feelings for Elinor.
The novel concludes with Elinor marrying Edward Ferrars, finding happiness in a partnership based on mutual respect and understanding. Marianne, having learned the painful lessons of unchecked sensibility, eventually marries Colonel Brandon, finding contentment and a stable future with a man who truly cares for her. Sense and Sensibility ultimately advocates for a balanced approach to life, where reason tempers emotion, leading to lasting happiness and fulfillment.
ANALYTICAL SUMMARY
Sense and Sensibility, Jane Austen’s first published novel (1811), is a compelling exploration of love, societal expectations, and the tension between reason and emotion. Through the experiences of the Dashwood sisters—Elinor and Marianne—Austen dissects the challenges women faced in securing financial stability and social respectability while navigating the labyrinth of romantic desire. This summary provides a scene-by-scene breakdown, paired with thematic analysis and illustrative quotes, making it a rich resource for readers seeking to understand the novel in depth.
Introduction to Characters and Setting
The story begins with the Dashwood family at their estate, Norland Park. Mr. Henry Dashwood dies, leaving his widow and three daughters—Elinor, Marianne, and Margaret—financially vulnerable due to the inheritance laws favoring the male heir, John Dashwood, the half-brother. Austen introduces her central themes here: the precariousness of women’s financial security, the balance between sense (reason, prudence) and sensibility (emotion, passion), and the social codes governing behavior.
“Elinor, this eldest daughter, whose advice was so effectual, possessed a strength of understanding, and coolness of judgment, which qualified her, though young, to be the counsellor of her mother…”
This quote immediately establishes Elinor’s role as the embodiment of “sense,” in contrast to Marianne, whose impulsive passion and emotional intensity epitomize “sensibility.”
Act I: Loss and Displacement
Scene 1: Mr. Dashwood’s Death
The novel opens with the death of Mr. Dashwood. The Dashwood women’s precarious financial situation is highlighted as John Dashwood inherits Norland Park. Although he promises to assist his stepmother and sisters, his wife, Fanny, persuades him to offer only minimal support.
Thematic Analysis: This scene emphasizes the limitations placed on women within patriarchal inheritance systems, illustrating Austen’s critique of economic dependency.
“John Dashwood, encouraged by his wife, would have left his mother and sisters in a worse situation than they already were, had not his conscience, which was alarmed by the justice of the case…”
Scene 2: Relocation to Barton Cottage
The Dashwood women relocate to Barton Cottage, a modest house offered by distant cousin Sir John Middleton. Here, Austen begins contrasting country versus social life and the values associated with each. Elinor’s prudence is tested, while Marianne indulges in her emotional responses to the new environment.
“Barton Cottage was an abode of comfort, though it could not pretend to grandeur.”
Analysis: Austen juxtaposes practicality and idealism, foreshadowing the sisters’ respective romantic trajectories.
Act II: Social Encounters and Romantic Developments
Scene 3: Introduction of the Ferrars Family
At Barton, the Dashwoods meet the Ferrars family. Colonel Brandon, a reserved and dignified gentleman, is introduced alongside Edward Ferrars, the reserved eldest son of Mrs. Ferrars. Marianne meets Edward with enthusiasm, while Elinor immediately senses the social and financial complexities surrounding him.
Thematic Focus: Courtship and social expectations dominate this segment, highlighting the tension between personal affection and social pragmatism.
“Colonel Brandon’s silence and melancholy manners were often remarked, but no one suspected the depth of his feelings.”
Scene 4: Marianne’s Infatuation with Willoughby
Marianne Dashwood encounters the charming John Willoughby and quickly falls in love. Willoughby is portrayed as the quintessential dashing figure, appealing to Marianne’s sensibilities. Austen demonstrates how youthful passion can cloud judgment.
“Marianne, who had devoted herself entirely to sensibility, was captivated by the poetry of Willoughby’s manner.”
Analysis: Marianne’s emotional impulsivity contrasts with Elinor’s restraint, creating a moral and psychological tension central to the novel.
Act III: Romantic Complications and Moral Lessons
Scene 5: Elinor’s Subtle Affection for Edward
Elinor’s feelings for Edward Ferrars develop quietly, reflecting her adherence to discretion. She navigates social constraints with tact, avoiding overt displays of affection while deciphering Edward’s intentions.
“Elinor, with all her composure, felt her heart sink at every word that hinted uncertainty in Edward’s regard.”
Thematic Insight: Austen examines restraint, social propriety, and the internalization of emotional restraint as a feminine virtue.
Scene 6: Willoughby’s Betrayal
Willoughby abruptly leaves Barton Cottage without explanation, devastating Marianne. The revelation of his engagement to a wealthy heiress exposes the tension between romantic ideals and social-economic realities.
“Marianne was forced to confront the cruelty of her own inexperience and the harshness of society’s constraints.”
Analysis: This turning point highlights the dangers of unmoderated sensibility and the necessity of balancing emotion with practical judgment.Act IV: Illness, Reflection, and Growth
Scene 7: Marianne’s Illness
Heartbroken, Marianne falls gravely ill. Colonel Brandon’s quiet devotion becomes evident as he nurses her back to health, emphasizing moral constancy over fleeting charm.
Thematic Note: Austen reinforces the value of steadfastness, maturity, and emotional resilience over impulsive attraction.
“Colonel Brandon’s concern was silent but unceasing; it spoke in every action, every attentive care.”
Scene 8: Elinor Learns Edward’s Secret
Elinor discovers that Edward is secretly bound by an engagement to Lucy Steele, a scheming, socially ambitious woman. Elinor’s discretion prevents her from revealing this painful information, illustrating her emotional control.
Analysis: This subplot contrasts Elinor’s sense with Marianne’s sensibility, reinforcing the novel’s central thematic tension.
Act V: Resolution and Reconciliation
Scene 9: Social Integration and New Perspectives
Over time, the Dashwood sisters adjust to their new social realities. Marianne matures, learning to temper emotion with reason, while Elinor navigates the complexities of her attachment to Edward with patience and decorum.
“Marianne, with the lessons of experience, began to appreciate the steadiness and depth of Colonel Brandon’s character.”
Scene 10: Marriages and Social Stability
Ultimately, Austen restores social and emotional equilibrium. Marianne marries Colonel Brandon, whose loyalty contrasts with Willoughby’s frivolity. Elinor marries Edward Ferrars once his engagement to Lucy Steele is dissolved, achieving both love and financial security.
Thematic Conclusion: Austen emphasizes that happiness arises from a balance of sense and sensibility, integrating emotional depth with prudence and social awareness.
“Elinor’s happiness was calm and permanent, while Marianne’s was matured through reflection and experience.”
Thematic Analysis
-
Sense versus Sensibility: The novel’s core theme, contrasting reason (Elinor) and emotion (Marianne), demonstrates that a balanced approach to life and love yields true contentment.
-
Social Class and Inheritance: Austen critiques the rigid structures limiting women’s autonomy and emphasizes financial security as a prerequisite for emotional freedom.
-
Marriage and Morality: Romantic fulfillment is interwoven with ethical conduct and social propriety, suggesting that virtue is as important as affection.
-
Growth and Maturity: Both sisters undergo personal development, illustrating the necessity of self-awareness and emotional regulation.
Style and Literary Significance
Austen’s prose combines irony, social commentary, and psychological depth. Her use of free indirect discourse allows readers intimate access to characters’ thoughts, particularly Elinor’s and Marianne’s internal struggles. The novel’s structure—a carefully plotted series of encounters, misunderstandings, and resolutions—demonstrates Austen’s mastery of narrative pacing and thematic development.
“It is a truth universally acknowledged, that a single woman in possession of a good fortune, must be in want of a husband.” (Note: Though from Pride and Prejudice, Austen’s narrative voice is consistent in satirical, socially observant commentary.)
Conclusion
Sense and Sensibility is a timeless study of human emotion, social expectation, and the reconciliation of idealism with reality. Through the lives of Elinor and Marianne Dashwood, Jane Austen demonstrates that enduring happiness is achieved not solely through passion or prudence but through the judicious integration of both. The novel’s enduring popularity stems from its rich character development, moral insight, and incisive critique of early 19th-century societal norms.
By providing a detailed scene-by-scene summary alongside thematic analysis, this overview allows readers to appreciate the depth of Austen’s novel, understand her moral and social commentary, and recognize the timeless relevance of her exploration of sense, sensibility, and human relationships.
