 |
Boberger. Photo: Bengt Oberger, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons Nadine Gordimer |
INTRODUCTION
Nadine Gordimer’s debut novel, The Lying Days (1953), is a semi-autobiographical coming-of-age story that captures both the personal and political awakening of a young white South African woman.
Told through the lens of Helen Shaw, a middle-class girl raised in a small mining town near Durban, the novel explores the tension between the insulated life of white privilege and the slow realization of the broader social injustices of apartheid.
This guide offers a detailed chronological summary of the novel’s key scenes, paired with a thematic analysis that highlights Gordimer’s use of personal narrative to probe systemic oppression, identity, and the struggle for truth in a society built on lies.
SHORT SUMMARY
Nadine Gordimer’s 1953 debut novel, "The Lying Days," meticulously chronicles the journey of Helen Shaw, a young white woman grappling with the complexities of her identity and a shifting sense of belonging in the apartheid-era suburbs of South Africa. The narrative is a profound exploration of personal and political awakening, set against a backdrop of racial segregation and societal hypocrisy.
The story unfolds through Helen’s first-person perspective, beginning with her idyllic but stifling childhood in the mining town of Clover Bay. Her formative years are defined by a sheltered existence, surrounded by a community that tacitly accepts the rigid racial hierarchy of the time. Gordimer uses this early section to establish the pervasive, insidious nature of apartheid's social conditioning, showing how its norms are deeply embedded in the daily lives of white South Africans.
Helen's sense of normalcy is gradually eroded as she begins to perceive the inherent injustices around her, a process sparked by her departure for university in Johannesburg.
In Johannesburg, Helen’s intellectual and emotional world expands dramatically. She is exposed to new ideas and a more diverse social milieu, leading her to question the values she was raised with. A pivotal part of her awakening comes through her relationships, particularly with two men who represent opposing paths: the conventional, reliable Ludi, and the more politically conscious and challenging Paul. It is through these relationships and her emerging friendships with people from different racial backgrounds that she begins to confront the "lying days"—the self-deceptions and societal falsehoods that have shaped her life.
The climax of the novel centers on Helen’s ultimate decision to leave South Africa. This isn’t merely a physical departure but a symbolic act of renouncing a system she can no longer reconcile with. Her flight is an acknowledgment that true freedom and moral integrity are unattainable for her within the confines of a society built on oppression. While the ending is not a simple resolution, it represents her final, painful break with a past she can no longer inhabit honestly.
"The Lying Days" is a crucial work in Gordimer's oeuvre, distinguished by its lyrical prose and psychological depth. It stands as a powerful indictment of apartheid, not through overt political polemic, but through the intimate, introspective journey of a single character. The novel’s enduring relevance lies in its exploration of themes that transcend its specific historical context: the search for authenticity, the moral responsibilities of the privileged, and the difficult process of forging an ethical identity in a morally compromised world. It remains a foundational text for understanding the literature of South Africa and the personal costs of political change.
ANALYTICAL SUMMARY
Part One: The Small Town and Childhood Illusions
Helen’s Early Life in the Mining Town
The novel opens in Gideon’s Town, a fictional mining community modeled after Springs, where Gordimer herself grew up. Helen lives in the cocoon of white middle-class life, surrounded by the rhythms of domesticity and the paternalistic ethos of her parents.
Her father is a mine manager, and her mother embodies the values of social conservatism and racial separation. Helen’s early experiences are shaped by the limited world around her, where black South Africans are visible only as servants or laborers. The novel begins with this atmosphere of stifling conformity and unspoken rules, where Helen is encouraged not to question the structures around her.
Helen describes this insularity in one of the book’s earliest reflections:
“It was as if the town itself had built walls around me, walls that kept out the confusion, the noise, the great questions of the world, and left only the clean pavements and the ordered gardens.”
Part Two: Schooling and Early Rebellion
Helen at School
As Helen attends school, she begins to glimpse the limitations of her upbringing. Her friendships expose her to new perspectives, though at this stage she remains largely passive, more curious than rebellious. Teachers reinforce the ideologies of racial hierarchy, and her classmates mirror the prejudices of their parents.
Awakening Through Books
Helen begins reading more widely, which becomes her first act of rebellion. Literature offers her a lens into other worlds, sparking both imagination and critical thinking. She realizes that much of her reality is constructed and not inevitable.
“Books had shown me another life, a life of unrest and uncertainty, but also of richness and meaning. I began to see that my own world was a place of small lies, of comfort bought at too high a cost.”
Part Three: University and the Expanding World
Leaving the Mining Town
Helen departs for the University of Natal in Durban, a move that marks her first real break from the confines of her family. This transition is pivotal; she is thrust into a broader intellectual and social environment where racial, political, and ideological debates can no longer be ignored.
“I left the town behind, the smell of the mine dumps, the ordered gardens, the sameness of every day. Ahead was a world that promised confusion, yes, but also the truth.”
Encounter with New Friends
At university, Helen meets peers who are far more politically conscious. She becomes close to figures like Paul, a politically engaged student who introduces her to radical critiques of South African society. Through these friendships, Helen encounters ideas of socialism, anti-apartheid activism, and interracial solidarity for the first time.
Part Four: Love, Desire, and Political Tension
Relationship with Paul
Helen falls in love with Paul, who is deeply involved in anti-racist politics. Their relationship is both romantic and ideological—Paul becomes a guide, pushing Helen to see beyond her sheltered upbringing. But it is also fraught with difficulty, as Paul’s commitment to political struggle often overshadows their personal connection.
Their conversations reveal the deep contradictions of white liberalism in South Africa: the tension between sympathy and action, between the personal risks of engagement and the comfort of privilege.
“With Paul I saw the world differently; the faces of the black men in the streets, the women with bundles on their heads, were no longer shadows but people whose lives had been stolen. Yet I felt at times that Paul belonged more to the struggle than to me.”
Conflicts at Home
Helen’s growing awareness creates tension with her parents. Her mother, in particular, represents the stubborn defense of racial segregation and conservative values. Arguments about politics, friends, and her future intensify, symbolizing the generational conflict between the insulated settler past and the uncertain, turbulent future.
Part Five: Encounters Beyond Whiteness
Crossing the Color Line
Through Paul and other politically active students, Helen begins to attend gatherings that bring her into direct contact with black South Africans as equals, not servants. These moments are revelatory and destabilizing.
She begins to understand both the richness of black culture and the crushing effects of apartheid’s restrictions. For the first time, Helen sees the stark contrast between her own freedom and the systemic oppression endured by the majority population.
“It was as if a veil had been lifted, and behind the veil lay a world that had always been there, only I had never been allowed to see it.”
Recognition of Complicity
Helen also confronts her own complicity as a beneficiary of the system. Even as she sympathizes with black South Africans, she recognizes that her position as a white woman affords her protections and privileges denied to others.
Part Six: Disillusionment and Growth
The Limits of Liberalism
As Helen deepens her involvement in political and intellectual circles, she becomes disillusioned with the limits of white liberal sympathy. She realizes that empathy without action is inadequate and that many white South Africans, even those critical of apartheid, are unwilling to risk their comfort.
“We wanted to believe we were different, that we were not like the others, but in the end we sat at the same tables, spoke the same words, and did nothing.”
The Collapse of Her Relationship
Helen’s relationship with Paul deteriorates. His political commitments and her growing independence create irreconcilable strains. The romance that once seemed to promise clarity now reveals only the difficulties of reconciling love with the demands of justice.
Part Seven: Return and Reflection
Revisiting Home
Toward the end of the novel, Helen returns to her family home in Gideon’s Town. The return is bittersweet—familiar yet irrevocably changed by her experiences. She sees her parents and her childhood world with new eyes, recognizing both their smallness and their humanity.
Acceptance of Uncertainty
The novel closes not with a triumphant political resolution but with Helen’s acceptance of uncertainty. She recognizes that truth is not a fixed state but an ongoing process of questioning and engagement.
“The lying days were over, yet what lay ahead was not clear truth but the struggle towards it, the knowledge that I could never again live in the safety of unknowing.”
Major Themes in The Lying Days
-
Illusion vs. Reality
-
Childhood represents the "lying days" of unexamined privilege. Adulthood is marked by the painful unveiling of systemic injustice.
-
-
Coming of Age in Apartheid South Africa
-
Helen’s journey mirrors Gordimer’s own awakening: a movement from ignorance to awareness, from conformity to critical questioning.
-
-
Love and Politics
-
Relationships in the novel symbolize ideological struggles. Love is never free from the pressures of history and society.
-
-
Alienation and Belonging
-
Helen’s growth alienates her from her family, her community, and even her lovers. Her identity is forged in this loneliness.
-
-
The Search for Truth
-
The novel refuses easy answers. Gordimer shows that truth is not a destination but an ongoing process.
-
Conclusion
Nadine Gordimer’s The Lying Days is both an intimate portrait of a young woman’s coming-of-age and a profound critique of apartheid South Africa. Through Helen Shaw’s journey, Gordimer explores how privilege, politics, love, and self-awareness intertwine in the painful process of growing up.
The novel’s power lies in its honesty: the acknowledgment that awakening is incomplete, messy, and fraught with contradictions. Helen does not arrive at clarity but at responsibility—the responsibility to live without illusions.
As Gordimer herself would continue to explore in her later works, The Lying Days is not just about one young woman’s growth but about a society struggling with its own self-deceptions. The novel remains a seminal text for understanding both the personal costs of apartheid and the universal struggles of coming of age.
