 |
| Doris Lessing Doris_lessing_20060312_(jha).jpg: Elke Wetzig (elya) derivative work: PRA, CC BY-SA 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons |
INTRODUCTION
Doris Lessing’s The Fifth Child (1988) is a haunting and unsettling novel that examines family, motherhood, societal expectations, and the clash between domestic ideals and uncontrollable forces of nature. At its core, the novel traces the story of Harriet and David Lovatt, whose dream of building a large, traditional family gradually unravels with the birth of their disturbing and “different” fifth child. Lessing’s sharp prose and sparse narration give the novel a chilling resonance, leaving readers unsettled by the ambiguous fate of both the family and society.
In this detailed breakdown, we’ll follow the chronological events scene by scene, exploring the themes of motherhood, otherness, isolation, social judgment, and the fragility of domestic ideals. Along the way, we’ll highlight some of Lessing’s key lines that underscore her vision.
SHORT SUMMARY
Doris Lessing’s The Fifth Child (1988) is a chilling and unsettling novel that explores family life, societal norms, and the fear of difference. At once domestic drama and modern gothic tale, it tells the story of Harriet and David Lovatt, whose seemingly perfect life unravels after the birth of their unusual fifth child. The novel examines themes of motherhood, normality, alienation, and the darker side of human nature.
Harriet and David’s Dream Life
The novel begins in 1960s England, where Harriet and David, both conservative in outlook, meet and quickly fall in love. Unlike their peers, they long for a large, traditional family. They buy a spacious house and fill it with children, holiday gatherings, and extended family reunions. Their home becomes a symbol of stability and joy, contrasting with the social upheavals of the era.
The First Four Children
Harriet and David’s dream seems to come true. Their first four children are healthy, happy, and well-adjusted. Family celebrations are warm and filled with laughter, and despite the financial strain of maintaining their large household, Harriet and David feel fulfilled. Their vision of family life—out of step with the changing values of the 1960s—appears idyllic.
The Arrival of the Fifth Child
Everything changes with Harriet’s fifth pregnancy. From the beginning, she feels something is different. The pregnancy is difficult and painful, and she experiences the unborn child as violent and alien within her. Relatives notice Harriet’s distress and become uneasy, but she insists on carrying the child to term.
Ben’s Birth
Harriet gives birth to Ben, the fifth child, and from the start he is unlike the others. He is unusually strong, demanding, and aggressive. His appearance is strikingly different: heavy-boned, muscular, and primitive in behavior. He seems unable to bond with Harriet or the family, and his presence creates tension, fear, and division in the household.
Family Strain and Isolation
As Ben grows, he becomes increasingly difficult to manage. He does not respond to affection, resists discipline, and frightens the other children. Relatives begin to avoid the once-welcoming household, and David distances himself emotionally, resenting Harriet’s insistence on protecting Ben. The once idyllic family is now fractured by mistrust, exhaustion, and fear.
Harriet’s Conflict
Despite the devastation Ben causes, Harriet remains deeply conflicted. As his mother, she feels compelled to love and protect him, even as she recognizes his destructive impact on the family. Her maternal instincts clash with her desire to preserve the happiness of her other children. Harriet’s isolation deepens as she realizes society has no place for children like Ben—unruly, uncontrollable, and resistant to categorization.
The Novel’s Climax and Ending
Eventually, Ben leaves the household to join a group of troubled youths, finding a sense of belonging in their marginal world. Harriet is left with profound guilt, torn between her duty as a mother and her recognition that Ben has destroyed the family she and David once dreamed of. The novel closes ambiguously, leaving readers unsettled about the limits of love, acceptance, and the price of difference.
Themes and Significance
The Fifth Child explores the fragile line between normality and abnormality within family life. Lessing highlights the societal pressures of conformity, the burden of motherhood, and the fear of what cannot be understood. The novel serves as a stark allegory about the limits of tolerance and the hidden darkness within domestic ideals.
ANALYTICAL SUMMARY
Part I: The Dream of Domestic Happiness
The Meeting of Harriet and David
The novel opens in 1960s England with the meeting of Harriet and David, a couple bound together by their mutual yearning for traditional family life. While the rest of their generation embraces social change and permissiveness, Harriet and David dream of stability, respectability, and—most importantly—many children.
Lessing presents them almost as outliers in their own generation:
“They had both recognized in each other the qualities of steadfastness, fidelity, and a passion for family.”
Their marriage is built on a shared ideal, and soon they acquire a large Victorian house, symbolizing permanence and solidity.
The House as a Gathering Place
The Lovatts’ large house soon becomes the hub of family life. Harriet and David invite relatives for long holidays, filling the home with noise, games, and celebrations. Their life is presented as idyllic: a traditional hearth glowing against the backdrop of a society increasingly leaning toward individualism and experimentation.
Lessing describes the house as a paradise of sorts:
“The big, comfortable house filled with children, cousins, aunts, uncles, and grandparents seemed like a dream made real.”
The Birth of the First Four Children
Harriet gives birth to four children in quick succession—Luke, Helen, Jane, and Paul. Each pregnancy strains Harriet physically and emotionally, but the family dream sustains her. Despite the difficulty, the children bring joy, laughter, and companionship.
However, cracks already begin to appear. David’s salary is stretched thin, and Harriet often feels overwhelmed. Yet she continues to press on, embodying the cultural ideal of maternal sacrifice:
“She wanted to rest, she wanted peace, but the thought of more children was also a fierce delight.”
Part II: The Arrival of the Fifth Child
The Unplanned Pregnancy
After their fourth child, Harriet becomes pregnant again—this time unexpectedly. From the beginning, this pregnancy is described in ominous tones. Harriet experiences violent movements in her womb, unlike anything she has known before. The fetus seems aggressive, restless, and alien.
Lessing writes:
“This one moved like a wild creature, fighting in her belly, kicking with a strength that hurt her.”
The Pregnancy’s Toll
Harriet suffers deeply during this pregnancy, alienating herself from others. Family gatherings become tense, with relatives expressing discomfort at Harriet’s swollen, pained figure. The communal joy of the earlier house parties fades.
The pregnancy itself disrupts the family rhythm: Harriet becomes bedridden, unable to tend to the other children, while David grows distant and uneasy.
Ben’s Birth
When the fifth child is born, his difference is undeniable. He is described as unusually large, with coarse features and an almost animalistic aura. The moment of his birth carries dread rather than joy:
“He looked like a troll, a goblin, some throwback to a more primitive species.”
Even as a newborn, Ben terrifies those around him with his strength and voracious appetite. Unlike the other children, he does not coo or bond. Instead, he seems alien, resistant to the rhythms of family affection.
Part III: The Decline of the Lovatt Household
Ben’s Infancy
As Ben grows, he becomes increasingly unmanageable. He breaks toys, hurts animals, and frightens his siblings. Harriet remains convinced that he deserves love, but others—including David—see him as dangerous.
Lessing describes his effect starkly:
“The other children avoided him, huddling together as if against an invader.”
The Breakdown of Extended Family Gatherings
The house no longer fills with relatives during holidays. Visitors are repelled by Ben’s presence, and the laughter of earlier scenes is gone. Harriet feels judged and condemned by her own relatives.
Institutionalization of Ben
Eventually, David pressures Harriet into sending Ben away to an institution. The family momentarily regains a sense of normalcy, and Harriet’s other children begin to thrive again. Yet Harriet is haunted by guilt, unable to shake the image of Ben locked away.
She reflects:
“She could not rid herself of the picture of him, small and alone, imprisoned.”
Part IV: Harriet’s Defiance
Harriet Rescues Ben
Unable to bear her guilt, Harriet visits the institution and finds Ben drugged, neglected, and near death. In an act of maternal defiance, she removes him and brings him home, despite David’s objections.
Her action shocks the family:
“She knew, with a kind of cold clarity, that in bringing Ben back she was breaking the family apart.”
Ben’s Return
When Ben returns, the other children’s lives begin to collapse. One by one, they withdraw or move away, unable to live under the same roof. David grows bitter, blaming Harriet for destroying their dream.
The house, once a symbol of hope, is now described as oppressive, haunted, and empty.
Ben and His “Tribe”
As Ben grows older, he gravitates toward rougher, delinquent youths, forming a kind of “tribe.” He is drawn to violence and strength, belonging more to outsiders than to his own family. Harriet recognizes this with resignation:
“He would never belong to her world, nor to David’s, nor to the house that had been their dream.”
Part V: Conclusion
The Broken Family
By the end of the novel, Harriet and David’s marriage is hollow. Their other children are scattered, their house desolate, their dream destroyed. Harriet lives in a state of grim endurance, tethered still to Ben, whose presence ensures the family’s isolation.
Lessing closes with a note of bleak inevitability:
“The Lovatts’ house stood silent, a monument to a dream that had been broken by a child who would never fit.”
Thematic Summary
-
Domestic Ideals vs. Reality—The Lovatts’ dream of a large, happy family collapses under the weight of unmanageable reality.
-
Motherhood and Sacrifice—Harriet’s maternal devotion both ennobles and destroys her, raising questions about the limits of unconditional love.
-
Otherness and Exclusion—Ben symbolizes the outsider who destabilizes social and familial order. His treatment reflects society’s impulse to ostracize the different.
-
Isolation and Judgment—The novel explores how quickly communities abandon those who deviate from norms.
-
Nature vs. Civilization—Ben embodies primal forces that civilized society cannot contain, a reminder of the fragility of order.
Conclusion
Doris Lessing’s The Fifth Child is a chilling exploration of the clash between idealism and reality. Through Harriet and David’s doomed pursuit of domestic perfection, Lessing examines how love, family, and community unravel when faced with the uncontrollable. With its Gothic undertones, sparse prose, and relentless gaze into maternal sacrifice, the novel remains a powerful meditation on what it means to belong—and what happens when someone doesn’t.
