INTRODUCTION
Joseph Boze, Public domain,
via Wikimedia Commons
Hilary Mantel (1952–2022) stands among the most significant and transformative voices in contemporary English literature. A novelist, short story writer, and essayist, she was renowned for her mastery of historical fiction and her ability to resurrect the past with astonishing clarity and psychological depth. Mantel’s career was marked by critical acclaim, literary prizes, and a wide readership that spanned the globe. Most notably, she was the first woman to win the Booker Prize twice for consecutive works, Wolf Hall (2009) and Bring Up the Bodies (2012), both part of her celebrated trilogy on Thomas Cromwell.
What distinguishes Mantel from her contemporaries is not only her subject matter but also her unique approach to storytelling. She resisted the romanticized narratives often associated with historical fiction. Instead, she created vivid, visceral worlds where politics, religion, and personal ambition intersected in complex, often violent ways. Her prose was both elegant and cutting, her narrative perspective daring, and her ability to inhabit the minds of her characters unparalleled.
This essay offers a comprehensive exploration of Hilary Mantel’s legacy, narrating at least five of her most influential novels, analyzing her recurring subjects, and examining the literary and historical influences that shaped her work.
1. Wolf Hall (2009)
Wolf Hall is perhaps Mantel’s most celebrated novel, a transformative work that redefined historical fiction for the twenty-first century. The book, the first in her Tudor trilogy, shifts the traditional perspective of the English Reformation away from kings and queens to focus instead on Thomas Cromwell, the blacksmith’s son who rose to become chief minister to Henry VIII.
Mantel’s Cromwell is a revelation. Previously depicted in history and popular culture as a ruthless schemer, Mantel reimagines him as a deeply intelligent, pragmatic, and emotionally complex figure. The narrative follows his rise from obscurity to influence, charting his role in the downfall of Cardinal Wolsey and his subsequent ascendancy at Henry’s court.
What makes Wolf Hall extraordinary is its perspective. Mantel uses an intimate third-person narration, almost entirely filtered through Cromwell’s consciousness, which allows readers to experience both the political machinations of Tudor England and the private pains of its characters. This narrative style brings immediacy and humanity to a period often treated as remote.
The novel’s thematic richness is equally compelling. It explores power, loyalty, faith, and survival in an age when a wrong step could lead to execution. At the same time, it paints a portrait of a man negotiating personal loss—Cromwell’s grief over his wife and daughters adds a profound emotional resonance to the novel.
Winning the 2009 Booker Prize, Wolf Hall became an international phenomenon, revitalizing interest in Tudor history and establishing Mantel as one of the greatest living novelists of her time.
2. Bring Up the Bodies (2012)
The second volume in Mantel’s trilogy, Bring Up the Bodies, continues Cromwell’s story, but with a darker and more focused lens. Where Wolf Hall depicts his rise, Bring Up the Bodies captures his role in the fall of Anne Boleyn.
The novel begins with Anne as queen, already failing to secure a male heir and losing Henry VIII’s favor. Cromwell, ever pragmatic, maneuvers to orchestrate her downfall, ensuring his own survival and the stability of the Tudor state. What follows is a taut narrative of betrayal, manipulation, and political ruthlessness.
Mantel’s genius lies in her refusal to oversimplify. Cromwell is both sympathetic and terrifying—a man of loyalty to his king but also a master strategist willing to destroy his enemies. His pursuit of Anne’s ruin is personal as well as political, tied to his memories of friends executed under her family’s influence.
The prose of Bring Up the Bodies is leaner and sharper than its predecessor, reflecting the narrowing of focus. The story feels like a tragic play, moving inexorably toward Anne’s trial and execution. Yet even in this grim narrative, Mantel illuminates the humanity of her characters, from Anne’s desperate dignity to Henry’s wavering self-justifications.
Awarded the 2012 Booker Prize, the novel secured Mantel’s place in literary history. Winning the prize twice in succession was an unprecedented achievement for a woman writer, and it underscored the power of her vision.
3. The Mirror and the Light (2020)
The final installment in the Cromwell trilogy, The Mirror and the Light, was one of the most anticipated novels of the twenty-first century. Published eight years after Bring Up the Bodies, it chronicles Cromwell’s zenith and inevitable downfall, from Anne Boleyn’s execution in 1536 to Cromwell’s own death by beheading in 1540.
Unlike the tightly focused narrative of its predecessor, The Mirror and the Light is expansive, spanning nearly four years of political intrigue, religious conflict, and personal reckoning. Mantel portrays Cromwell at the height of his power, orchestrating alliances, managing Henry’s marriages, and shaping the Reformation. Yet the shadow of mortality hangs over the novel, and readers sense that his fall is inevitable.
What distinguishes this book is its meditation on power and transience. Cromwell, once the consummate survivor, becomes ensnared in the same political machinery he mastered. Mantel’s narrative is elegiac, capturing both the grandeur of his achievements and the fragility of human ambition.
Stylistically, the novel is as rich as its predecessors, filled with Mantel’s characteristic wit, psychological insight, and sharp dialogue. At times slower and more reflective, it rewards patient readers with moments of profound revelation.
Though it did not win the Booker, The Mirror and the Light was hailed as a triumph, completing a trilogy often described as the finest historical fiction of the century.
4. A Place of Greater Safety (1992)
Before turning to Tudor England, Mantel demonstrated her historical vision in A Place of Greater Safety, an epic novel about the French Revolution. Written over a decade but published in 1992, the book follows three central figures: Georges Danton, Maximilien Robespierre, and Camille Desmoulins, charting their rise and fall amid the chaos of revolution.
The novel showcases Mantel’s ability to blend meticulous historical research with vivid storytelling. She captures both the grandeur of revolutionary ideals and the brutality of political violence. The characters are not distant historical icons but flesh-and-blood individuals, torn between ambition, loyalty, and ideology.
What is remarkable about A Place of Greater Safety is its scope. Mantel portrays not only the revolutionaries but also the ordinary citizens whose lives were upended by the upheaval. The narrative moves seamlessly from the salons of Paris to the tumult of the streets, creating a panoramic view of history in motion.
Although overshadowed at the time by her later works, this novel laid the foundation for her approach to historical fiction. It established her as a writer who could tackle vast historical canvases without sacrificing psychological depth. Many readers now recognize it as a precursor to the Cromwell trilogy, demonstrating Mantel’s lifelong interest in power, ideology, and human frailty.
5. Beyond Black (2005)
While Mantel is best known for her historical novels, Beyond Black showcases her range as a writer of contemporary fiction. The novel tells the story of Alison Hart, a medium who communicates with the dead while struggling with the haunting presence of her own traumatic past.
Alison is accompanied by her business partner, Colette, who views her psychic abilities with skepticism but profits from them nonetheless. As the story unfolds, Alison’s ghosts—both literal and metaphorical—become increasingly oppressive, forcing her to confront the dark secrets of her childhood.
At once a ghost story and a psychological novel, Beyond Black reveals Mantel’s fascination with the unseen forces that shape human life. It blends satire of contemporary suburban culture with chilling explorations of memory, trauma, and the afterlife.
Critics praised the novel for its originality and unsettling power. Though different in setting from her historical works, it shares their preoccupations: the interplay between past and present, the persistence of memory, and the complexity of human consciousness.
Beyond Black was shortlisted for the Orange Prize and is often cited as one of Mantel’s finest achievements outside the Tudor novels. It demonstrates her versatility and her willingness to explore the boundaries of genre.
Her Choice of Subjects
Hilary Mantel’s oeuvre is unified by her fascination with power, history, and the human psyche. Whether writing about Tudor courtiers, French revolutionaries, or contemporary mediums, she consistently chose subjects that interrogated the forces shaping human destiny.
A central theme is the relationship between the individual and history. Mantel’s characters are rarely passive observers; they are agents who make decisions with profound consequences. Cromwell, Robespierre, and Alison Hart all embody the tension between personal desire and historical or supernatural forces beyond their control.
Another recurring subject is memory and trauma. Mantel herself endured chronic illness and difficult personal experiences, and her fiction reflects a deep awareness of suffering and resilience. Her characters often carry invisible scars, and the past intrudes constantly into the present.
Finally, Mantel was drawn to the ambiguities of morality. Her novels resist simple judgments, portraying power as both necessary and corrupting, ambition as both admirable and destructive. By blurring the line between villain and hero, she compels readers to confront the complexity of human motives.
Her Influences
Mantel’s influences were wide-ranging, spanning literature, history, and personal experience.
-
She was often compared to Robert Bolt and Shakespeare for her dramatic rendering of history, though her prose style was distinctly modern and intimate.
-
The psychological depth of her characters reflects the influence of Henry James, whose focus on consciousness and perception shaped her narrative techniques.
-
She also admired Dame Iris Murdoch for her philosophical explorations of morality, and Muriel Spark for her sharp wit and irony.
-
Beyond literature, Mantel’s Catholic upbringing and later rejection of faith informed her preoccupation with religion, sin, and redemption.
-
Her personal struggles with illness gave her insight into the fragility of the body and the persistence of memory, themes that surface repeatedly in her work.
These influences, combined with her prodigious historical research, allowed Mantel to create a body of work that was both intellectually rigorous and emotionally powerful.
Conclusion
Hilary Mantel’s literary career is a testament to the power of imagination, research, and narrative daring. Through novels such as Wolf Hall, Bring Up the Bodies, The Mirror and the Light, A Place of Greater Safety, and Beyond Black, she reshaped the landscape of historical fiction and demonstrated the capacity of literature to bring the past vividly into the present.
Her choice of subjects—figures caught in the web of power, history, and memory—reflected her lifelong fascination with the interplay between individual will and larger forces. Influenced by both literary predecessors and her own experiences, she crafted novels of extraordinary depth, wit, and humanity.
Mantel’s legacy is secure as one of the greatest novelists of her generation. She not only gave readers unforgettable characters and narratives but also expanded the possibilities of historical fiction. In her work, the past is not a distant country—it is alive, visceral, and profoundly connected to our present struggles.
Her voice, both fierce and compassionate, continues to resonate, ensuring that Hilary Mantel will be remembered as a literary architect of history and imagination.
